Caldara - Christmas Cantata (Vaticini di Pace)
Sinfonias Nos. 5 & 6
From as early as 1676 until 1740, one of the features of
Christmas celebrations in baroque Rome was the performance of a cantata on
Christmas eve in the Palazzo Apostolico. Each year a composer, usually one
based in Rome, was selected to provide the music and after the Christmas Eve
Vesper service the Pope and his invited guests would retire to supper and to
hear the new cantata performed by the best singers in the papal choir.
In 1713 the Venetian-born Antonio Caldara (1670-1736) was
to provide the
Cantata da recitarsi la Notte del SSmo Natale
nel Palazzo Apostolico. He had been in Rome since 1709 as maestro di
Cappella to Francesco Maria Ruspoli, Prince of Cerveteri, and very likely the Christmas
cantata written for his patron in 1712 secured him the 1713 commission. It is
the earlier work that we have here, and the "per il SSmo Natale"
inscribed on the surviving manuscript of the Vaticini di Pace suggests
that Ruspoli, perhaps Rome's most lavish patron of the arts, was imitating papal
tradition. In one respect, however, Caldara's Christmas cantata performed in Ruspoli's
Palazzo Bonelli in 1712 did have a direct connection with the Vatican. The
libretto of Vaticini di Pace was not new. In 1703 Paolo Gini's text,
rich in allusions to the contemporary political scene, had been performed (in Domenico
Bottari's setting) at the Palazzo Apostolico. Nearly a decade later, in the
midst of efforts to heal the longstanding rift between the Pope (Clement XI)
and the Holy Roman Emperor (Charles VI), Ruspoli's re-use of this particular
libretto seems quite deliberate.
The estrangement was a legacy of the war of the Spanish
succession. From its beginnings in 1701 Italy had been embroiled in this
conflict between Bourbon and Habsburg for the Spanish throne. Even the Pope was
not immune. At first carefully neutral, he eventually sided with the Bourbon
cause. In May, 1708,
Habsburg armies, triumphant across northern Italy,
threatened the eternal city.
Ruspoli raised militia in its defence. Forced so
ignominiously to acknowledge
Charles III, the Austrian contender for the Spanish
kingdom, it is no surprise that the Pope exacted revenge three years later when
that same claimant, as Charles VI, suddenly succeeded to the imperial throne in
Vienna and to the title of Defender of the Faith. Clement withheld papal
recognition.
On the eve of the Treaty of Utrecht (1713), the finale of
the Spanish saga, Ruspoli found himself in a unique position. This loyal
supporter of the Pope now was also the patron of a composer who, after a visit
to Vienna between 1711 and 1712, was highly regarded by the Emperor himself.
Through a prominent performance of his maestro's new
setting of Gini's libretto
Ruspoli ensured that Clement XI's early concerns for
peace and Italy's troubled state (barely disguised in Core umano's plaintive:
"Bella pace; ove sei? Care
spiaggie latine ...prive ancor voi del mio tesoro amato?")
were well remembered just prior to the diplomatic negotiations from which the
church was to be excluded. He saw too that Gini's flattering allusions to
Clement XI ("un sol Clemente la Clemenza Regnante La Clemente amica stella"),
propagandist patriotism in 1703, now would help restore an image tarnished by
military miscalculation, for the Pope was about to lose territory under the Utrecht
settlement. But perhaps above all, Ruspoli hoped a lesson in reconciliation
might be learned from the change of heart displayed by Gini's seemingly
implacable Giustitia. Indeed, Clement XI did relent - eventually. His confirmatio
electionis is of February, 1714, finally acknowledged Charles VI as Holy
Roman Emperor. The prophecy of peace had come about.
Today, these considerations of politics and prestige bear
little on our appreciation of Caldara's music. The composer himself seems to
have paid them scant attention, content to focus on what Gini offered by way of
character differentiation, varying emotional states and opportunity for musical
symbolism.
Core umano, an allegorical Everyman, desires peace
("Pace bella ridi a noi") - a peace which, conceived in human terms,
means a cessation of martial activities.
That peace, says Pace ("Vuoi pace al core"),
can only come from an inner spiritual peace and, to achieve this, true
repentance is necessary. The absence of an outward peace reflects the disarray
of humanity's soul. Amor Divino, a universal intermediary and the protector of
Core umano, offers hope: although war is the reward for mankind's turning from
the true path, God will forgive the guilty. In "Quel bianco latte" -a
lullaby inspired by a vision of the Virgin and Child - Amor Divino pleads for
mercy, not retribution on those who offend the Almighty.
Ciustitia, who represents the avenging righteousness of
the Old Testament, remains unmoved ("Che dici, che pretendi"); errors
must be punished, despite pleas for forgiveness. In "Da nemica ultrice spada"
and again in "Si, si, perira" angular vocal phrases and powerful
figurations for unison violins conjure up terrifying retribution. In " Amor
trionfera" Amor Divino comforts an anguished Core umano faced with
bewildering options ("Ciustitia vuol ch'io pera").
If Ciustitia will not listen to entreaty, perhaps the
crying of the innocent Holy-infant will bring about a change of heart. In
"Qual pargoletto infante" Pace confronts Ciustitia with the merciful
justice of the New Testament, personified in the Christ-child. For this lyrical
moment Caldara invokes some of the traditional imagery of the Nativity. The
gentle siciliano rhythm of the aria captures the pastoral setting of the holy
birth; delicate intertwinings of voice and violins in senza basso
scoring enhance the serenity of contemplative devotion. Ciustitia is persuaded.
From henceforth justice will be tempered with mercy ("Cia vi sento intenerir"),
and the reconciliation of Pace with Ciustitia is complete in "1 tuoi bacci",
the only concerted vocal movement in the cantata.
The contrite Core umano, now assured of forgiveness, not
retribution, extols
Christ's nativity in "Bella notte" before
returning to the initial request, the plea for universal peace. Both Amor Divino
("No, no non piu crudel") and Pace ("La clemente amica stella")
prophesy that this will quickly follow, and Amor Divino concludes the cantata
with a eulogy of peace ("Quanto dolce"). Its benefits to mankind are
recounted, mirrored in the broad sweep of the ornate violin accompaniment.
In the summer of 1716 Caldara left Ruspoli and Italy to
take up the position of Vizekapellmeister to the Imperial court in Vienna.
There, one of his many tasks was to contribute to the sequence of oratorios
performed each year in the Hofkapelle during the weeks immediately preceding
Easter. By the time of his death in December, 1736, he had written 23 such
works for the court chapel.
The two sinfonias featured here are actually the
overtures (or "Introduzione" as
Caldara termed them) to his oratorios San Pietra in Cesarea
(1734) and Sant' Elena al Calvario (1731). Originally two-movement (adagia-allegra)
structures full of contrapuntal writing, we now hear each sinfonia in a unique
version that includes a second pair of slow-fast movements. The author of these
additions remains unknown but probably was not Caldara. Both Sinfonias are from
a collection of twelve similarly-enlarged overtures and the existence of this
manuscript in the archive of the Minorite monastery in Vienna, suggests this
music had been specially selected and adapted for performance during the more
elaborate ceremonies of the Order.
© 1996 Brian W. Pritchard