Anton
Rubinstein (1829-1894)
Symphony
No. 4 in D Minor, Op. 95 "Dramatic"
It
was Gustav Mahler who described himself as three times homeless: a Bohemian in
Austria; an Austrian among Germans; a Jew throughout the whole world. The
nineteenth century provided chances for Jewish assimilation into a Gentile
world. The Jewish poet Heine described baptism as a ticket into European
culture, and it was a course chosen by some, such as the Mendelssohn family and
in Russia by the Rubinsteins. Nevertheless, as Jewish fortunes prospered,
anti-Semitism became more overt. There is no doubt that Anton Rubinstein's
reputation suffered because of his racial origins, much as it suffered among
Russian nationalists as a result of his obviously cosmopolitan or German
musical proclivities.
Anton
Rubinstein was born at Vikhvatinets in the Podolsk district of the Russian
Empire, on the borders of Moldavia, in 1829. A few years later his family moved
to Moscow, and after early instruction on the piano from his mother he took
lessons from a teacher there, a certain Villoing, later to be the teacher of
his brother Nikolay. He gave his first public concert in Moscow at the age of
ten. There followed four years of touring as a child virtuoso, years that took
him to Paris, to Scandinavia, Austria and Germany, and to London, where he
played for Queen Victoria. In 1844 the family settled in Berlin, where
Rubinstein took lessons in harmony and counterpoint from Glinka's former
teacher, the Prussian royal music librarian Siegfried Dehn.
In
1846 Rubinstein's father died and the rest of the family returned to Russia,
while he remained abroad in Vienna and in Pressburg (the modern Bratislava),
earning a living as he could by teaching and cynical about the support that the
apparently generous Liszt semed to offer, which took the form of a visit to his
garret in Vienna, with his entourage of disciples. As a pianist Rubinstein
rivalled Liszt in fame, and the latter spoke of him with grudging respect as a
composer and player, a clever fellow, but unduly influenced by the classicism
of Mendelssohn, adding a less charitable description of him as the
pseudo-Musician of the future on the occasion of a visit to Weimar in 1854 for
the first performance of his opera The Siberian Huntsmen (Sibirskiye okhotniki).
Rubinstein's
fortunes had changed as a result of a meeting with members of the Russian
Imperial family during the course of an earlier visit to Paris. On his return
to Russia in the winter of 1848 he found support from the Grand Duchess Elena
Pavlovna, a German princess and sister-in-law of the Tsar. With her active
encouragement he established in 1859 the Russian Musical Society and three
years later the St. Petersburg Conservatory. His brother Nikolay, whose
childhood prowess as a pianist had enjoyed similar exposure, founded a
companion Conservatory in Moscow. Tchaikovsky was among the first students of
the St. Petersburg Conservatory and among the first teachers on the staff of
its counterpart in Moscow.
The
new Conservatory aroused immediate enmity, in particular from the nationalist
group of composers, bullied into collaboration by the eccentric Balakirev.
Rubinstein had tactlessly opened battle by attacking the whole notion of
national opera, pointing to the alleged failure of Glinka's work. Balakirev,
self-taught as a composer, objected to formal German musical training, and it
was left to following generations to benefit from a profitable synthesis of the
relatively primitive nationalism of the Five and the cosmopolitan
sophistication and technical accomplishment of the Conservatories. Rubinstein,
however, coupled technical assurance with a less overtly Russian approach,
although by the time of his death in 1894 he had come to a better understanding
of Russian nationalism in music, while a younger generation had come to
appreciate the necessity of professional musical training.
Rubinstein
was director of the St. Petersburg Conservatory until 1867, when he also gave
up the direction of the Russian Music Society concerts, which now fell to Balakirev.
He returned to direct the Conservatory once more in 1887, towards the end of a
career that had established him as one of the greatest contemporary pianists
and as a conductor of significant ability. As a composer he was prolific,
leading his younger brother Nikolay, when asked about his own compositions, to
reply that Anton had written enough for both of them. As a symphonist he was
regarded by Tchaikovsky as, with Joachim Raff, the leading exponent of the
time, far superior to the mediocre Brahms and to Wagner, who had perversely
turned his back on the symphony.
By
the end of his life, however, Rubinstein had lost the respect of the younger
generation, so that his name had, for them, become synonymous with kitsch -
c'est du Rubinstein had become a familiar jibe. His name was jocularly changed
to Tupinstein (dimwit) or Dubinstein (idiot) and Balakirev churlishly refused
to attend the celebration of Rubinstein's 60th birthday in 1889. It is only
now, with hindsight, that we can begin to reassess his very remarkable and
substantial achievement in opera, and in orchestral and chamber music, as well
as in his writing for the piano, so long remembered invidiously only by the
notorious Melody in F.
Rubinstein
wrote his fourth symphony in 1874, the year of his eleventh opera, Die
Makkabäer. He conducted a performance at the Crystal Palace in London during
the course of a visit to England in 1877, when he also introduced to the
English public his Ocean Symphony, pejoratively described by Mussorgsky as "a
puddle". The first three movements of the Dramatic Symphony are scored,
with all the clarity of Mendelssohn, for the normal classical orchestra, with
pairs of flutes, oboes, clarinets, bassoons, trumpets, French horns and timpani
and strings. The symphony opens with a slow and ominous introduction, a violin
motif entering above the sinister motif entrusted to cello and double bass. A
dramatic Allegro moderato, where both motifs are used gives way to a more
lyrical theme and a third of heroic triumph. The movement is in the prescribed
classical form, with a central development that introduces some new material,
before the return of the original themes, the first of which ends the movement.
The
second movement Scherzo, again in D minor, includes passages of delightful
interplay between pairs of wind instruments. There is a contrasting section
with a solo violin, over an ostinato bass and a Trio in D major, before the
return of the opening Scherzo. The F major Adagio opens with the strings
playing a long-drawn melody. The woodwind at first predominate in a second
theme, over a running violin accompaniment. Divided cellos and double bass
introduce a flute solo and the woodwind return to the first theme before the
end of the movement. Drama erupts again in the final movement, which opens with
a slow introduction, to which trombones and piccolo are now added, before the
unison strings embark on the Allegro con fuoco, with its angular opening theme.
A second theme, in F major and marked Moderato assai, is ushered in by the
first violins. There is a contrapuntal interlude for woodwind, based on an
accompanying figure first heard in the opening bars of the symphony and an
extended passage derived from the principal theme, before the return of the
forceful theme itself. The second theme now returns in A major, played by the
French horn. The symphony ends in heroic D major triumph.
Czecho-Slovak
State Philharmonic Orchestra (Košice)
The
East Slovakian town of Košice boasts a long and distinguished musical
tradition, as part of a province that once provided Vienna with musicians. The
State Philharmonic Orchestra is of relatively recent origin and was established
in 1968 under the conductor Bystrik Rezucha. Subsequent principal conductors
have included Stanislav Macura and Ladislav Slovák, the latter succeeded in
1985 by his pupil Richard Zimmer. The orchestra has toured widely in Eastern
and Western Europe and plays an important part in the Košice Musical Spring and
the Košice InternationalOrgan Festival.
For
Marco Polo the orchestra has made the first compact disc recordings of rare
works by Granville Bantock and Joachim Raff. Writing on the last of these, one
critic praised the orchestra for its competence comparable to that of the major
orchestras of Vienna and Prague. The orchestra has contributed several
successful volumes to the complete compact disc Johann Strauss II and for Naxos
has recorded a varied repertoire.
Robert
Stankovsky
Robert
Stankovsky was born in Bratislava, the capital of Slovakia, in 1964, and after
a childhood spent in the study of the piano, recorder, oboe and clarinet,
turned his attention, at the age of fourteen, to conducting, graduating in this
and in piano at the Bratislava Conservatory with the title of best graduate of
the year. Stankovsky is regarded as one of the best conductors of the younger
generation in Czechoslovakia. For Marco Polo Stankovsky has recorded symphonies
by Rubinstein and Miaskovsky in addition to orchestral works by Dvořák and
Smetana.