Anton
Rubinstein (1829-1894)
Symphony
No. 5 in G Minor, Op. 107
Overture:
Dmitry Donskoy
Faust,
Op. 68
It
was Gustav Mahler who described himself as three times homeless: a Bohemian in
Austria; an Austrian among Germans; a Jew throughout the whole world. The
nineteenth century provided chances for Jewish assimilation into a Gentile
world. The Jewish poet Heine described baptism as a ticket into European
culture, and it was a course chosen by some, such as the Mendelssohn family and
in Russia by the Rubinsteins. Nevertheless, as Jewish fortunes prospered,
anti-Semitism became more overt. There is no doubt that Anton Rubinstein's
reputation suffered because of his racial origins, much as it suffered among
Russian nationalists as a result of his obviously cosmopolitan or German
musical proclivities.
Anton
Rubinstein was born at Vikhvatinets in the Podolsk district of the Russian
Empire, on the borders of Moldavia, in 1829. A few years later his family moved
to Moscow, and after early instruction on the piano from his mother he took
lessons from a teacher there, a certain Villoing, later to be the teacher of
his brother Nikolay. He gave his first public concert in Moscow at the age of
ten. There followed four years of touring as a child virtuoso, years that took
him to Paris, to Scandinavia, Austria and Germany, and to London, where he
played for Queen Victoria. In 1844 the family settled in Berlin, where
Rubinstein took lessons in harmony and counterpoint from Glinka's former
teacher, the Prussian royal music librarian Siegfried Dehn.
In
1846 Rubinstein's father died and the rest of the family returned to Russia,
while he remained abroad in Vienna and in Pressburg (the modern Bratislava),
earning a living as he could by teaching and cynical about the support that the
apparently generous Liszt semed to offer, which took the form of a visit to his
garret in Vienna, with his entourage of disciples. As a pianist Rubinstein
rivalled Liszt in fame, and the latter spoke of him with grudging respect as a
composer and player, a clever fellow, but unduly influenced by the classicism
of Mendelssohn, adding a less charitable description of him as the
pseudo-Musician of the future on the occasion of a visit to Weimar in 1854 for
the first performance of his opera The Siberian Huntsmen.
Rubinstein's
fortunes had changed as a result of a meeting with members of the Russian
Imperial family during the course of an earlier visit to Paris. On his return
to Russia in the winter of 1848 he found support from the Grand Duchess Elena
Pavlovna, a German princess and sister-in-law of the Tsar. With her active
encouragement he established in 1859 the Russian Musical Society and three
years later the St. Petersburg Conservatory. His brother Nikolay, whose
childhood prowess as a pianist had enjoyed similar exposure, founded a
companion Conservatory in Moscow. Tchaikovsky was among the first students of
the St. Petersburg Conservatory and among the first teachers on the staff of
its counterpart in Moscow.
The
new Conservatory aroused immediate enmity, in particular from the nationalist
group of composers, bullied into collaboration by the eccentric Balakirev.
Rubinstein had opened battle by attacking the whole notion of national opera,
pointing to the alleged failure of Glinka's work. Balakirev, self-taught as a
composer, objected to formal German musical training, and it was left to
following generations to benefit from a profitable synthesis of the relatively
primitive nationalism of the Five and the cosmopolitan sophistication and technical
accomplishment of the Conservatories. Rubinstein, however, coupled technical
assurance with a less overtly Russian approach, although by the time of his
death in 1894 he had come to a better understanding of Russian nationalism in
music, while a younger generation had come to appreciate the necessity of
professional musical training.
Rubinstein
remained director of the St. Petersburg Conservatory until 1867 , when he also
gave up the directorship of the Russian Music Society concerts, which now fell
to Balakirev. He returned to direct the Conservatory once more in 1887, towards
the end of a career that had established him as one of the greatest
contemporary pianists and as a conductor of significant ability .As a composer
he was prolific, leading his younger brother Nikolay, when asked about his own
compositions, to reply that Anton had written enough for both of them. By the
end of his life, however, he had lost the respect of the younger generation, so
that his name had become synonymous with kitsch - c'est du Rubinstein had
become a familiar jibe. It is only now, with hindsight, that we can begin to
reassess his very remarkable and substantial achievement in opera, orchestral
and chamber music, and in his writing for the piano, so long remembered invidiously
only by the notorious Melody in F.
Rubinstein
wrote the fifth of his six symphonies in 1880. The first movement opens with a
thoroughly Russian theme, entrusted to the woodwind, a section that also
embarks on the second subject, a theme of less obvious national provenance. The
material is treated with Rubinstein's usual Mendelssohnian economy of means and
technical competence according to established classical procedure. An equally
Russian theme is passed from clarinet to oboe, to flute and to the violins, in
the first theme of the second movement scherzo, with its contrasted minor trio
section, dominated by more melancholy national sentiments. A solo French horn
sets the mood of the slow movement, followed by the lively thematic material of
the finale, brought together in a finely crafted conclusion. Modern writers
have commented on the connection between this symphony and Tchaikovsky's First
Symphony, in the same key, a work written as a student of Rubinstein, and again
very much under the influence of Mendelssohn. Yet Rubinstein's Fifth Symphony
is in no sense either merely derivative or a shadow of his pupil's work.
Dedicated to the memory of the Grand Duchess Elena Pavlovna, to whose support
he owed his career, the symphony is Russian in its melodies, but lacks any of
the crudity that can be found all too often in the contemporary work of the
dilettante nationalist composers then in the ascendant.
Rubinstein's
first opera, Dmitry Donskoy, attempted a thoroughly national Russian theme. It
was completed in 1850 and first staged in St. Petersburg two years later. The
subject of the opera, derived from the pseudoclassical drama of Vladislav
Alexandrovich Ozerov, is the grand prince of Moscow who in the fourteenth
century defeated the Tatars and established the supremacy of Muscovy. Prince
Dmitry's title, Donskoy, is a reference to the site of his second victory. The
opera had little success, leading Rubinstein to declare nationalism in opera an
impossibility, while accusing nationalist composers, with some justification,
of dilettantism. It is of significance to notice that Rimsky-Korsakov,
recalling in later life his early experience of opera in St. Petersburg,
mentions "somebody's opera" Dmitry Donskoy.
Faust,
written in 1864, originally formed part of a Faust symphony. The single
movement that Rubinstein preserved was described as a musical picture after
Goethe. In this respect the music speaks for itself, following something of the
fortunes of Faust from the study to rejuvenation and later retribution,
narrowly avoided.
Horia
Andreescu
The
Romanian conductor Horia Andreescu was born in Brasov in 1946 and received his
musical training at the Academy in Bucharest and at the Vienna Music Academy,
where his teachers included Hans Swarowsky and Karl Oesterreicher. He has won a
number of awards, national and international, and has appeared in major cities
in Eastern and Western Europe.