Ralph Vaughan Williams (1872-1958) Job, A Masque for Dancing The Lark Ascending Ralph Vaughan Williams belonged to a time of burgeoning cultural, aesthetic...
Ralph Vaughan Williams
(1872-1958)
Job, A Masque
for Dancing
The Lark Ascending
Ralph Vaughan Williams
belonged to a time of burgeoning cultural, aesthetic and spiritual diversity,
to a generation embracing Debussy, Richard Strauss, Sibelius, Scriabin, Rachmaninov,
Schoenberg, Ives, Ravel, Falla, Respighi, Medtner, Bartok, Stravinsky and
Szymanowski. His years spanned two world wars, the history of England's sunset
from Empire to Commonwealth. Musical revolution, the New German School of Liszt
and Wagner; Stockhausen, Boulez and the Darmstadt radicals, framed his life. In
the succession of major Anglo-Saxon composers, he imposingly commanded the high
ground between Elgar and Britten, facing "the doubts and portents of a
tragic age" where his predecessor had "proudly" summed up
"the glories of the Victorian century" (Bernard Shore). He has been
called "the apotheosis of Englishness", "the fountainhead of the
... English national school", a man ''as English as Morley and
Purcell". In 1931, the year of Job at the ISCM Festival, Aaron
Copland, fresh from Brooklyn, jazz and Nadia Boulanger, arrogantly wrote him
off as "the kind of local composer who stands for something great in the
musical development of his own country but whose actual musical contribution
cannot bear exportation... His is the music of a gentleman farmer, noble in
inspiration but dull". Fifteen years later, the critic Scott Goddard was
to say: "There is no aspect of life foreign to him, none beyond the reach
of his art; and that art, which is the most individual in the history of
[British] music since Purcell, has reached a width of reference and a depth of
comment never attained by musicians bred here... Nothing can be said
conclusively about the workings of mind so protean and still magnificently
active". The "corpus of Vaughan Williams's work will speak to
generations of Englishmen of a great Englishman's ranging thoughts, his love of
the homely countryside, his piety, his inherited poetry, his adventurous mind
and lofty ideals" (Shore, 1949).
A Victorian
clergyman's son from Brahmsian Gloucestershire, Vaughan William was a master of
words no less than sounds. He believed that music was to be heard, not so much
read or spoken about. "In our imperfect existence what means have we of
reaching out to that which is beyond the senses but through those very senses?
Would Ulysses have been obliged to be lashed to the mast if the sirens instead
of singing to him had shown him a printed score? When the trumpet sounding the
charge rouses the soldier to frenzy, does anyone suggest that it would have
just the same effect if he took a surreptitious glance at Military Sounds
and Signals?" (Music & Letters, April 1920). In his book National
Music (published in 1934 from lectures given two years previously) he argued
that fundamentally all music was a matter of nationality, and therefore
nationalistic. Ruling states had identities and dialects as individual and
"narrowly" circumscribed as those of their satellites. "National
music is not necessarily folk-song; on the other hand folk-song is, by nature,
necessarily national". Music, he believed, was "the only means of
artistic expression which is natural to everybody. Music is above all things
the art of the common man ... the art of the humble... Music cannot be treated
like cigars or wine, as a mere commodity. It has its spiritual value as well.
It shares in preserving the identity of soul of the individual and of the
nation". "The great men of music close periods; they do not
inaugurate them," he wrote famously. "The pioneer work, the finding
of new paths, is left to smaller men... I would define genius as the right man
in the right place at the right time ...we shall never know of the number of
'mute and inglorious Miltons' who failed because the place and time were not
ready for them. Was not Purcell a genius born before his time? Was not Sullivan
a jewel in the wrong setting?... As long as composers persist in serving up at
second-hand the externals of the music of other nations," he concluded
famously, "they must not be surprised if audiences prefer the real Brahms,
the real Wagner, the real Debussy, or the real Stravinsky to their pale
reflections. What a composer has to do is to find out the real message he has
to convey to the community and say it directly and without equivocation... if the
roots of your art are firmly planted in your own soil and that soil has
anything individual to give you, you may still gain the whole world and not
lose your own souls". Such was his creed.
Proceeding, in places
even anticipating, the violent Fourth Symphony, Job, A Masque for Dancing (1927-30),
to a scenario by Sir Geoffrey Keynes, dates from the period between the operas Sir
John in Love (Shakespeare) and Riders to the Sea (Synge). As
compelling in the concert-hall (symphonically) as the theatre (dramatically),
it has been claimed that "it marks the emergence of English ballet,
allowing it at a crucial moment to free itself from imitative influence"
(Michael Kennedy, 1964). Central to its biblical inspiration were William Blake's
twenty-one watercolours for the Book of Job (1820-26), the paintings of
Botticelli and Rubens, images and quotations from the Old Testament story, the
English Restoration masque tradition (earlier explored in On Christmas
Night, 1926), and characteristic Elizabethan and Jacobean dance types - the
sarabande, minuet (stylistically "formal, statuesque and slightly
voluptuous," VW imagined), pavane and galliard. "In Job," Kennedy
summarises, "Vaughan Williams found satisfaction in translating Blake's
drawings into sound; he was not at all concerned with their symbolism ... Job's
pastoral life, Satan's machinations, and Heaven are clearly defined in music.
Blake's pictures combine eloquence with simplicity. So does the music ... a
perfect reconciliation of the various elements in [the composer's] style: the
lyrical ('pastoral') side, the folk-dance rhythms, the aggressive 20th century
harmonies [and syncopations - illustrative of Satan and Hell] the Purcellian
diatonic splendour of a great tune [visions of 'Heaven and the throne of
God']".
The concert version
was first heard on 23rd October 1930 in St Andrew's Hall, Norwich, as part of
the Norwich Festival, with the Queen's Hall Orchestra under the composer.
Conducted by Constant Lambert, the stage première, presented by the Carmargo
Society at the Cambridge Theatre, London, 5th July 1931, had scenery and
costumes by Gwendolen Raverat, wigs and masks by the dancer Hedley Briggs, and
choreography by Ninette de Valois. Following a (forgotten) independent performance
in New York, 25th August 1931, the Sadler's Wells Ballet company brought their
celebrated Covent Garden production to America, 2nd November 1949, at the
Metropolitan Opera, New York, with Robert Helpmann in the rôle of Satan created
originally by Anton Dolin. By then the first gramophone recording of the work
had already been made (produced by Walter Legge for HMV in March 1946 at the
Abbey Road Studios), with Sir Adrian Boult, the dedicatee, conducting the BBC
Symphony Orchestra. It was Boult who had been responsible for introducing the
concert version to America before and after the War - in the summer of 1939
with the Chicago Symphony Orchestra at Ravinia Park, and in January 1946 with
the Boston Symphony.
The endurance of faith
over affliction, "this drama of heaven and hell" (Richard Capell), Job
divides into nine heavily-mimed scenes, scored for forces including
saxophone, organ and a large percussion battery. The following is a precis of
the composer's extended synopsis published in the full score (1934).
Scene I
Introduction - Pastoral Dance - Satan's Appeal to God - Saraband of the Sons of
God (Largo sostenuto - allegro piacevole - doppio più lento - andante con moto
- largamente). "Hast
thou considered my servant Job?" Job and his family sitting in quiet
conversation surrounded by flocks and herds. Dance of Job's sons and daughters.
Job stands up and blesses his children, saying "It may be my children have
sinned". Everyone kneels. Angels appear at the side of the stage. Enter
Satan, who appeals to heaven. Heaven gradually opens and displays God sitting
in majesty surrounded by the Sons of God. The line of angels stretches from
earth to heaven. A light falls on Job. God regards him with affection and says
to Satan "Hast thou considered my servant Job?" Satan says "Put
forth thy hand now and touch all that he hath and he will curse thee to thy
face" .God says" All that he hath is in thy power". Satan
departs. The dance of homage begins again. God leaves his throne.
Scene II Satan's
Dance of Triumph (Presto - con fuoco - moderato alla marcia - presto). "So Satan went forth from the presence of
the Lord". Heaven is empty and God's throne vacant. Satan alone on the
stage. He dances, and climbs up to God's throne and kneels in mock adoration.
The hosts of Hell enter running and kneel before Satan who has risen and stands
before God's throne facing the audience. Satan in wild triumph and with a big
gesture sits in God's throne. (In his entertaining sketch, A Musical
Autobiography [1950], Vaughan Williams wrote: "I have never had any
conscience about cribbing. I cribbed Satan's dance in Job deliberately
from the scherzo of Beethoven's last quartet". First heard in Scene I,
Satan's motif - an angular falling major seventh and minor ninth - relates
clearly enough to the leaping figures of the Beethoven, and more especially its
jolting syncopated major ninth drops. But might there also perhaps have been a
further, undisclosed source, the "evil" falling major sevenths from
Mussorgsky's Baba Yaga, likewise curiously centred on the same note, G?)
Scene III Minuet of
the Sons of Job and Their Wives (Andante con moto). "Then came a great wind and smote the four
corners of the house and it fell upon the young men and they are dead".
Enter Job's [seven] sons and their wives in front of the curtain. They hold
golden wine cups in their left hands. The black curtain draws back and shows an
interior. Enter Satan. The dance stops suddenly. The dancers fall dead.
Scene IV Job's
Dream. Dance of Plague, Pestilence, Famine and Battle (Lento moderato -
allegro). "In thoughts
from the visions of the night ...fear came upon me and trembling". Job is
quietly sleeping. He moves uneasily in his sleep and Satan enters. Satan stands
over Job and calls up terrifying visions of plague, pestilence, famine, battle,
murder and sudden death who posture before Job. The dancers headed by Satan
make a ring round Job and raise their hands three times. The vision gradually
disappears.
Scene V Dance of
the Messengers (Lento - andante con moto - lento). "There came a messenger". Job wakes
from his sleep and perceives three messengers, who arrive one after the other,
telling him that all his wealth is destroyed. A sad procession passes across
the back of the stage, culminating in the funeral cortège of Job's sons and
their wives. Job still blesses God. "The Lord gave and the Lord hath taken
away, blessed be the name of the Lord".
Scene VI Dance of
Job's Comforters. Job's Curse. A Vision of Satan (Andante doloroso - poco più
mosso - ancora più mosso - Tempo I - andante maestoso). "Behold, happy is the man whom God
correcteth". Satan introduces in turn Job's three Comforters (three wily
hypocrites [Blake's supposition]). Their dance is at first one of pretended
sympathy, but develops into anger and reproach. Job stands and curses God.
"Let the day perish wherein I was born". Heaven gradually becomes
visible, showing mysterious veiled, sinister figures moving in a sort of parody
of the Sons of God in Scene I. Heaven is now lit up. The figures throw off their
veils and display themselves as Satan enthroned, surrounded by the hosts of
Hell. Satan stands. Job and his friends cower in terror. The vision gradually
disappears. (In Keynes's scenario, Scenes V and VI were originally linked as
one.)
Scene VII Elihu's
Dance of Youth and Beauty. Pavane of the Sons of the Morning (Andante
tranquillo (tempo rubato) [with
solo violin] - allegretto - andante con moto). "Ye are old and I am
very young". Enter Elihu, a beautiful young man. "I am young and ye
are very old". "Then the Lord answered Job". Heaven gradually
shines behind the stars. Dim figures are seen dancing a solemn dance [pavane].
As Heaven grows lighter, they are seen to be the Sons of the Morning dancing
before God's throne.
Scene VIII Galliard
of the Sons of Morning. Altar Dance and Heavenly Pavane (Andante con moto -
allegro pesante - allegretto tranquillo - lento). "All the Sons of God shouted for
joy". Enter Satan. He claims the victory over Job. God pronounces sentence
of banishment on Satan and the Sons of Morning gradually drive him down. Satan
falls out of Heaven. "My servant Job shall pray for you". Enter (on
earth) young men and women playing on instruments; others bring stones and
build an altar. Others decorate the altar with flowers. Job must not play on an
instrument himself. He blesses the altar. The Heavenly dance [pavane] begins
again, while the [altar] dance on earth continues.
Scene IX Epilogue
(Largo sostenuto). "So
the Lord blessed the latter end of Job more than his beginning". Job, an
old and humbled man, sits with his wife. His friends come up one by one and
give him presents. Job stands and gazes on the distant cornfields. Job's three
daughters enter and sit at his feet. He stands and blesses them.
Quintessentially
English, the idyllic, dreaming pastoral romance The Lark Ascending for
violin and orchestra (1914, rev 1920) is among the best known of Vaughan
Williams's shorter occasional pieces. In its orchestral form it was first given
in the old Queen's Hall, London, on 14th June 1921, played by the dedicatee,
Marie Hall, with the British Symphony Orchestra under Boult. The music is
prefaced by extracts from the poem of the same name by George Meredith
(1828-1909): "He rises and begins to round, / He drops the silver chain of
sound, / Of many links without a break, / In chirrup, whistle, slur and shake.
/ For singing till his heaven fills, / 'Tis love of earth that he instils, /
And ever winging up and up, / Our valley is his golden cup, / And he the wine
which overflows / To lift us with him as he goes. / [MS of violin and piano
score, British Library: "He is the dance of children, thanks / Of sowers,
shout of primrose banks / And eyes of violets while they breathe; / All these
the encirling song will breathe..."] Till lost on his aerial rings / In
light, and then the fancy sings." The cadenza-like blossoms and raptures
of the Lark's infinitely variable song, Andante sostenuto, enfold a
quicker folk-like section, Allegretto tranquillo (quasi andante).
1997 Atefş Orga