Boris Ivanovich Tishchenko (b.1939): Symphony No. 7
Often considered the direct heir to the legacy of
Shostakovich, Boris Ivanovich Tishchenko was born in Leningrad on 23rd March
1939. Studies with Galina Ustvolskaya, a one-time pupil of Shostakovich, and at
the Leningrad Conservatory led to his taking a postgraduate course with
Shostakovich during the years 1962 to 1965. Active as a pianist, both as a
soloist and in chamber music, he has taught at the Leningrad - now once more
the St Petersburg - Conservatory since 1965, becoming a professor there in 1986.
With a list of some 130 works to his credit, Tishchenko is a
prolific composer who has contributed to all the major genres. Folk and ethnic
music have both played their part in his thinking, together with composers as
diverse as Monteverdi and Mahler, in an idiom whose undogmatic approach to
tonal thinking won him the
approval of Shostakovich early in his career. This is particularly evident in
the Third of his eleven symphonic works (1966), which the older composer
singled out for the "richness of its emotions, its clarity of thought and its
structural logic", and the First Cello Concerto, written for Rostropovich in
1963 and re-orchestrated by Shostakovich for more conventional forces in 1969.
Such an empathy reached its apogee in the Fourth and Fifth Symphonies, composed
before and after Shostakovich's death in 1975, where an avowedly public
symphonism is pursued in impressively large-scale terms.
After these Tishchenko turned more to chamber and
instrumental music (he has composed ten piano sonatas and five string
quartets), and choral works, only returning to orchestral symphonic writing
with his Seventh Symphony (1994). The work consists of five movements, a
restrained slow movement framed by what might be termed a scherzo and
intermezzo, and framed in their turn by substantial outer movements which
exhibit a free though resourceful approach to symphonic form, such as can be
found in Shostakovich's later symphonies and string quartets.
The first movement of the symphony begins with a fragment on
muted trumpet, alternating with clarinet over pizzicato strings, before violins
introduce a more wistful idea. These are heard in varied combinations before
the clarinet idea gravitates to lower strings, then timpani, over which strings
and bassoons pursue a hesitant discussion. Violins and upper woodwind, then
brass enter as the mood grows more animated, arriving at a lively, rather
sardonic dance, then a vigorous fugato dominated by trombone slides. The dance
recommences, culminating in a brief climax based on the violins' wistful idea,
which continues as the movement moves back to its beginning, and a decidedly
equivocal conclusion.
The second movement opens with a call to attention from
brass, and a vigorous dance to which piano and xylophone make an unexpected but
characterful contribution. The music builds to a riotous climax, in which the
dance is angrily taken apart by timpani and tom-toms. It then continues with
somewhat desperate jollity, passing through a passage of intensive string
polyphony before regaining its initial focus. A skittering ascending gesture
from piano, and the movement is brutally curtailed.
A plaintive oboe melody, accompanied by viola but gently
offset by muted trombone, begins the third movement. Upper woodwind gradually
coalesce into plangent discords, then into a series of repeated gestures in
combination with trumpets and horns. The initial melody returns low in the
bassoons, joined by other woodwind in a passage of increasingly dissonant
polyphony, which reaches an ominous peak. The main idea again returns on low
woodwind, and the movement ends somberly.
A graceful theme for violins is the main thematic element in
the fourth movement, wryly commented on by woodwind and brass, which latter
introduce a chorale motif as contrast, with some notably bizarre downwards
woodwind glissandi as it evolves. The opening theme at length returns as a
hushed string fugato, the mood growing livelier as woodwind hint at the chorale
motif and muted strings press towards a culmination that merely evanesces into
fragmentary recalls of the opening theme.
Over pulsating tom-toms, the fifth movement opens with a
lively theme for piccolo and violins in alternation, passing to other woodwind
as a further passage of dissonant polyphony is built up. Strings and woodwind
now introduce a more decisive idea, which gravitates to the lower reaches of
the orchestra before moving towards a lengthy fugato on the main theme. At its
height the decisive idea is hammered out, and discussion of this continues energetically
on brass and strings. The main theme now becomes the subject of lively debate
in strings and woodwind, yet with the texture becoming ever sparer as it slows
to a musing pause. At this point the main theme breaks out anew on the whole
orchestra, bringing the symphony to a forceful yet hardly conclusive ending.
Richard Whitehouse