Charles Tomlinson Griffes (1884-1920) Complete Piano Works, Volume 1 Charles Tomlinson Griffes was born in Elmira, New York, in 1884. His talents recognized...
Charles Tomlinson Griffes (1884-1920)
Complete Piano Works, Volume 1
Charles Tomlinson
Griffes was born in Elmira, New York, in 1884. His talents recognized and
shaped by a devoted piano teacher, the gifted boy determined on early to become
a musician. Like virtually all other American musicians of that era, upon
reaching young manhood he went to Europe to become properly
"finished."
In his case, he
went to Berlin for four years to continue his piano studies, work on musical
composition with Englebert Humperdinck, and generally soak up modern European
culture. Upon his return to the States in 1907, Griffes secured a job as music
director at the Hackley School in Tarry town, New York, a private boys
preparatory school. He was 23 years old - an accomplished pianist, well trained
composer, cultured, worldly, fluent in four languages, sensitive, curious, and
ambitious. He was a voracious reader (particularly of poetry), had a
fascination for Asian art and culture, painted (mostly watercolors), and was
eager to throw himself into the creative fray of nearby New York City.
A mere thirteen
years later, in 1920, the composer was dead at the age of only 35. He had just
achieved renown following Pierre Monteux's successful performances of The Pleasure-Dome of Kubla Khan with the
Boston Symphony in Boston and Carnegie Hall a few months before. Despite his
tragically short life, Griffes created a significant and beautiful body of
music while undergoing remarkable stylistic evolutions. His early death
represents a particularly unfortunate loss since we can only speculate as to
the musical paths he would have travelled had he lived longer.
Griffes began
writing for the piano as a child. His juvenilia include short, Chopinesque
pieces such as 4 Preludes, a
Mazurka, and a set of Variations. Though sensitive and endearing, they give
only a small hint of what was to come. I have included the plaintive B-Minor Prelude as a little homage to his
childhood. This is the first time it has been recorded.
The piano music
that Griffes wrote in Europe was greatly influenced by Wagner, Richard Strauss,
Humperdinck, and the German Romantics. During this period abroad Griffes
learned his craft and began his evolution from student to master. He completed
two large works for two pianos, and worked on four unfinished piano sonatas. A Winter Landscape was composed around
1912, and published in 1997 for the first time. It is noble and dramatic in
scope, and evocative of late Liszt and Wagner. Still unpublished and dating
from c.1910 is a beguiling arrangement of the famous Barcarolle, "Belle Nuit, O Nuit d' Amour" from the
Tales of Hoffmann by Offenbach, in the tradition of the Liszt lieder
transcriptions. Both of these pieces as well are receiving their first recorded
performances with this disc.
During the twelve
years in which Griffes lived and taught at the Hackley School and created most
of his piano music, his academic existence was largely drudgery on behalf of
disinterested students. "Oh! how they bore and weary me!" he wrote.
His constant trips into Manhattan, however, were stimulating. He met many of
the European avant-gardists and heard new scores by composers such as Debussy,
Ravel, Scriabin, Stravinsky, Schoenberg, Busoni, Milhaud, Prokofiev, and
Varese. He was also well aware of fellow American composers including Ornstein,
Loeffler, and Farwell. Griffes tirelessly and assiduously promoted his music
and these efforts, combined with the quality of the music, began to payoff. He
was beginning to receive significant performances by prominent pianists,
singers, string quartets, and major orchestras and conductors. He was given
orchestral premieres by the New York Symphony under Damrosch, the Boston
Symphony under Monteux, and the Philadelphia Orchestra under Stokowski. His
music was greeted with encouragement from musicians and critics and met with
audience success. In 1919, just before he died, he was becoming established as
one of the most gifted and creative American composers of his generation.
Though many have
attached the sobriquet" American Impressionist" to Griffes' name, the
description is in reality only partially accurate. Throughout his life, Griffes
was vividly aware of current trends and phases in music, dance, and theatre,
and his own works absorbed and reflected that awareness. Impressionism was just
one such influence. In his best compositions his own unique talents and
sensibilities shine forth; the music is original.
The Three Tone-Pictures, Op.5, the composer's
first published piano works, make a beautiful and effective set. Begun in 1910
and later revised, they were published by G. Schirmer in 1915 on the
recommendation of Busoni. With them, Griffes left the German romanticism of his
early music and created a unique impressionistic style. Fragmentary in nature,
they are filled with chromaticism, tonal ambiguity, creative pedal effects, and
a subtle sense of color and imagination. They show Griffes as a master
miniaturist and tone-poet. The Lake at
Evening is haunting and hypnotic, perfectly capturing the spirit of
the Yeats poem which inspired it "lake water lapping with low sounds by
the shore." In ABA form, it is dominated by a simple ostinato figure which
creates a sense of unity and tranquility. The other two Tone-Pictures are
prefaced by poems of Edgar Allan Poe. The
Vale of Dreams has a disturbing quality, conjuring up a troubled
subconscious. It utilizes extreme chromaticism, melodic parallel thirds, and an
unsettled tonality. Sensual and voluptuous, it is possessed of a dark and
almost decadent sadness. The Night Winds flies
up and down the keyboard in a shimmering spray of notes, the sighing left hand
melody surrounded by a torrent of wholetone based arpeggios. A sort of
"baby" Feux d'Artifice (Debussy),
the ending is reminiscent of that of Ravel's Scarbo.
Roman Sketches, Op. 7
take the composer into an even more personal sound-world. They are all prefaced
by poems of William Sharp, a favorite of Griffes, from a collection
called" Sospiri di Roma. "
The once-famous first piece is The White
Peacock, a musical portrayal of this rare and exotic albino bird who
had great mystical meaning for Griffes. The music perfectly captures the proud
opening of plumage, the peculiar strut, the bird's tremendous sense of majesty
and pride. The harmonic language is convincing and confident, the sense of
color and use of rhythm compelling. One encounters unusual chords, intensely
chromatic harmonies, and asymmetrical rhythmical phrases and groupings. Nightfall follows - a dark, depressed
vision, employing mysterious syncopations, long ostinatos, two big climaxes,
subtle and difficult voicings, and a highly evolved sense of pianistic
coloration. Nightfall, as in much
of Griffes' piano writing, often involves the use of all three pedals and very
modern harmonic overlappings. The Fountains
of the Acqua Paola is harmonically the most conservative of the
four, with glittering technical brilliance. It is an attractive water piece in
the tradition of Ravel's Jeux d'eau and
Liszt's Les jeux d'eaux à la Villa d'Este. Featuring a beautiful left-hand
melody decorated by right-hand arpeggios and double notes, the music
successfully captures the shimmer and spray of foam and fountains. Clouds is in many ways the most
harmonically adventuresome of the Roman
Sketches, with masterful use of bitonality. Some of it is notated on
four staves, the first instance of this in Griffes' writing. It is slow and
tranquil, with strange and unsettling phrases expressing a sense of wonderment
at the slow-moving mountainous glory of colorful and snow-like clouds. It is
interesting to note that Griffes, like Scriabin, associated tonalities with
specific colors -for example, C Major was "an incandescent white light,
the brightest key of all." He was conscious of this as he tried to suggest
the "golden domes and towers of a city with streets of amethyst and
turquoise," whose literary vision inspired Clouds.
De Profundis, like the Roman
Sketches, was composed in 1915 and prefaced by a poem by William
Sharp. This piece was a favorite of Griffes' friends and admirers. The composer
referred to it as his "tribute to Wagner," as it contains an almost
Tristan-like romanticism. The ardent melodies are touching and poignant, the
harmonies curious and haunting. The rising figure with which it opens lingers
in the memory, and its return is emotionally reassuring after the climactic
middle section.
The Rhapsody in B Minor was completed in 1914,
and first published in 1984. It is very much in the style of Liszt's Hungarian
Rhapsodies, many of which Griffes performed and admired. (Griffes,
incidentally, was prophetic in appreciating the late works of Liszt, and in
feeling that much of his output was misunderstood and underrated.) Dazzling and
difficult, it is an extroverted virtuoso piece with many lyrical qualities as
well. Rhapsodic in form, it conveys a feeling of fantasy and improvisation.
Conservative in idiom, it is made up of a variety of contrasting sections
featuring very attractive themes which constantly change key signature, meter,
and character.
The Legend is a touching little piece, dating
from 1915. Written in only two days, it was published posthumously, but the
score has long been unavailable. In ABA form, lasting only 141 measures, it is
a sort of sad and nostalgic waltz. There are some unusual harmonic turns in the
middle section, which utilizes the whole-tone scale. It has a bittersweet
quality which lingers in the memory. It seems somewhat reminiscent of Debussy's
La Plus que Lente or Liszt's Valse Ouhliee No.1.
If most of the
works written after his "Germanic" period reveal impressionistic
influence, the great Piano Sonata of
1919 boldly strikes out into uncharted territory. Griffes had by now
established himself as a master miniaturist, a composer of rare finesse and
delicacy. The Sonata could not be
more different or ambitious - here he shows command of a large form, in a work
of superb craftsmanship and almost primal power. Unlike most of his previous
piano works, the Sonata has no specific imagery or programmatic intent - it is
pure and absolute, ruled only by sound and rhythm. It was very modern for its
time, and confused some early listeners. But pianists and sophisticated
musicians realized that they were hearing something both new and significant.
Virgil Thomson called it "shockingly original." Rudolf Ganz said, "Charles
Tomlinson Griffes'
new Piano Sonata is the finest
abstract work in American piano literature. It is free of all foreign
influences. He is going his own way." Harold Bauer wrote that "the Sonata is a splendid piece of writing,
broad and noble in outline, subtle in atmosphere. It will not attract the crowd
- it is technically very difficult - but it will deeply appeal to the serious
musician. From a man who can write such music, we may look for even greater
things."
The Sonata is in three movements. The first and second
movements are played without pause, and the short break between movements two
and three is precisely notated, creating the effect of a one-movement sonata.
The entire Sonata is permeated with inventive use of dissonances (especially
tritones and augmented intervals), as well as with such exoticisms as
pentatonic scales, whole tone chords, and Japanese, Balinese, and American
Indian music. There is also a more extensive use of counterpoint than Griffes'
piano music had used before. Although the Sonata has a strong gravitational
pull to D Minor, it is largely based on a scale of his own invention. This
scale, functioning at times almost like a tone row, is D, E-Flat, F, G-Sharp,
A, B-Flat, C-Sharp, (D). The constant use of this scale's augmented seconds
enables Griffes to avoid a sense of major-minor tonality. The first movement is
in clear sonata form. The opening, marked "Feroce", is startling and
barbaric, furiously launching the music upwards into existence. The main body
of the movement is marked Allegretto con moto. There are a great variety of
textures, and visceral contrasts between lyricism and drama. There is a feeling
of late Romantic sensibilities in a modern setting. The first movement ends with
a tremendous climax, out of whose deterioration the second movement begins.
This middle movement, Molto tranquillo, is very modal, chant-like, and free in
form. It contains great simplicity as well as moments of extreme agitation. It
ends with a dramatic crescendo and accelerando, leading directly into the
finale. This final movement, an "Allegro vivace" in 6/8 time, is
dominated by an exciting repeated note theme and driven by tremendous rhythmic
propulsion. There are drum and tympani effects, extreme dynamic contrasts, and
a quotation from the slow movement. The impassioned and difficult coda employs
cross-rhythms, left-hand leaps, octaves, and powerful chords to bring the
Sonata to a thrilling conclusion.
As with all
original works, it must be approached, understood, and performed on its own
terms. The Sonata exists in a
novel tonality, and the character of the themes is largely determined by
intervallic relationships. Its rhythms are angular, and the often irregular and
unusual phrases rarely fall into standard groupings. There can be no doubt that
it represents a milestone in the evolution of the American piano sonata and the
realization by Griffes of a new and completely personal style that was in many
ways prophetic of the direction that American concert piano music was to take
in the twentieth century. It is sad that he had time only for one more piano
work after this Sonata, the
sparse and haiku-like Preludes.
Ironically,
Griffes' successes in 1919 were probably the major cause of his untimely death.
Lacking the money to pay people to copy all of the orchestral parts required
for performances, he sat up nights writing out them out himself. The flurry of
excitement and overwork took a toll on his health. The doctors diagnosed his
illness as a combination of emphysema, influenza, and pneumonia; probably
caused by physical and nervous exhaustion. An operation on his lungs failed to
help him, and he died in New York Hospital on April 8, 1920.
The piano music of
Charles Tomlinson Griffes resonates with his distinctive and imaginative
artistic personality. Griffes was graced with rare gifts of description, a
creative and cultivated sensitivity toward harmonies and colors, and an
estimable melodic mastery. His brief life was a constant evolution toward an
ever more forward thinking musical language. He left an important and
multifaceted stamp on music and played a notable role in the evolution of
American and twentieth century musical history. Had he lived longer he might
very well have become one of the great composers. As it is, the singular legacy
of works that he left us is very fine indeed and deserving of continued and
heightened appreciation.
Program Notes by
Michael Lewin, 1998.
Notes and
Acknowledgements
Material from these
program notes first appeared in the May/June issue of Piano & Keyboard Magazine, from an article written by Michael Lewin
entitled Griffes: An Appreciation. Michael Lewin expresses his deep
appreciation to Donna K. Anderson, author of Charles
T. Griffes: A Life in Music, whose
generous assistance has helped make this recording possible. The Griffes
watercolor on the cover was provided courtesy of Donna K. Anderson. The Sonata, Three Tone-Pictures, Op.5, and
Roman Sketches, Op.7 are
published by G. Schirmer. De Profundis, A Winter
Landscape, and Rhapsody in B
minor are published by C.F. Peters (Henmar Press). The Legend in F sharp minor is published
by Charles Scribner's Sons. The Barcarolle ("Belle
Nuit") and Prelude in B minor are
unpublished and are recorded with the permission of the copyright owner, Donna
K. Anderson. All rights reserved.
Michael Lewin
American pianist
Michael Lewin enjoys an active international career, lauded for his virtuosity,
poetry, and intelligence. His competition honors include the 1986 Liszt Competition
in the Netherlands, the 1983 Beethoven Fellowship Award in Indianapolis, and
the1982 Kapell International Competition at the University of Maryland, along
with grants from the Rockefeller Foundation and the National Endowment for the
Arts. Mr. Lewin performs annually throughout the United States and Canada, and
regularly tours Europe and Asia. His orchestral engagements include the
Netherlands Philharmonic, Cairo Symphony, Taipei Philharmonic, Camerata
Budapest, the Boston Pops Orchestra, the Symphonies of Phoenix, Indianapolis,
New Orleans, Colorado Springs, Nevada, West Virginia, the Chamber Orchestra of
Puerto Rico and the Jupiter Symphony. He has performed in New York's Lincoln
Center, Boston's Symphony Hall, Hong Kong's City Hall Theatre, Taipei's
National Concert Hall, the Great Hall in Moscow, the Opera House of Cairo, the
Muziekcentrum Vredenburg in Holland, and the Spoleto Festival. Michael Lewin
graduated from the Juilliard School in New York; his teachers have included
Irwin Freundlich, Leon Fleisher and Yvonne Lefebure.
He lives in Boston,
where he teaches at the Boston Conservatory and is the Artistic Director of the
Boston Conservatory Chamber Players. His earlier recordings include music by
Liszt, Scriabin, Balakirev and Glazunov. Forthcoming is a volume of Scarlatti
Sonatas for Naxos.